Nation Deeply Divided Over ICE Activities: New Poll Reveals Stark Divisions
Locales: Texas, Arizona, California, Florida, UNITED STATES

Washington D.C. - January 31st, 2026 - A comprehensive new poll released today by the American Values Institute (AVI) paints a stark picture of a nation deeply divided over the activities of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The findings reveal a complex interplay of concerns regarding national security, human rights, and the very nature of immigration enforcement in the United States. While nearly half of Americans believe current ICE activity is necessary for border control and national safety, a significant minority expresses serious reservations about potential abuses and the human cost of these operations.
The AVI poll, conducted with a sample size of 1,200 American adults (margin of error +/- 3%), delves into the perceptions surrounding ICE's role in immigration enforcement, revealing pronounced divisions based on political affiliation, age, and geographic location. The results suggest that the debate surrounding immigration isn't merely about policy; it's about fundamentally different values and priorities.
A Nation Split: The Numbers Behind the Divide
The poll indicates that 48% of American adults believe the current level of ICE enforcement is "necessary to maintain national security and border control." However, 35% express "concern over the impact of these operations and the potential for abuse," with a further 17% remaining undecided or holding no strong opinion. This split underscores the difficulty policymakers face in navigating the complexities of immigration reform.
Political Polarization: A Widening Gulf The partisan divide is particularly striking. A resounding 72% of Republicans surveyed support the current level of ICE activity, prioritizing border security and upholding existing immigration laws. In sharp contrast, 61% of Democrats voiced concerns, citing worries about the separation of families, the treatment of asylum seekers, and the overall human rights implications of ICE's operations. This alignment with party lines suggests that perceptions of ICE are heavily influenced by pre-existing political ideologies.
Generational Divide: Younger Americans Question Enforcement Tactics The poll also uncovered significant generational differences. Younger voters, aged 18-34, demonstrate a marked skepticism toward ICE. Over 50% of this demographic expressed concerns about human rights violations and the disruption of families, often pointing to documented cases of wrongful detention and deportation. Conversely, older voters (65+) exhibit a stronger inclination to support the current approach, emphasizing the vital importance of maintaining secure borders. This suggests a potential clash of values between generations, with younger Americans prioritizing compassion and human rights while older generations prioritize security.
Regional Disparities: The Impact on Immigrant Communities The AVI poll further highlighted regional variations in public opinion. States with substantial immigrant populations, such as California, Texas, and Florida, consistently reported higher levels of concern regarding ICE activity. Residents of these states appear more attuned to the direct impact of enforcement operations on their communities, witnessing firsthand the fear and disruption caused by increased ICE presence. States with smaller immigrant populations, meanwhile, tend to exhibit stronger support for current enforcement levels.
Beyond Security: The Human Cost and the Call for Reform
Dr. Eleanor Vance, lead researcher at the AVI, emphasized the significance of the poll's findings. "These results demonstrate that the issue of ICE activity isn't a simple one," she stated. "There is a clear need for a more nuanced discussion about how we balance border security with the protection of human rights. The public is becoming increasingly aware of the human cost of enforcement, and this awareness is likely to fuel demands for comprehensive immigration reform."
The poll's release comes at a critical juncture in the national debate over immigration. Calls for increased transparency and accountability within ICE have been growing in recent years, fueled by reports of misconduct and allegations of abuse. Activist groups are demanding an end to practices such as family separation and the detention of vulnerable populations. Meanwhile, proponents of stricter enforcement argue that robust border security is essential to national security and economic stability.
Looking ahead, the findings of the AVI poll suggest that any future attempts at immigration reform must address the concerns of all stakeholders. Balancing the need for secure borders with the protection of human rights will require a commitment to dialogue, compromise, and a willingness to acknowledge the complex realities of immigration in the 21st century. The poll serves as a powerful reminder that the American public is not monolithic in its views on ICE and that finding common ground will be a significant challenge in the years to come.
Read the Full KOTA TV Article at:
[ https://www.kotatv.com/2026/01/20/americas-pulse-current-ice-activity-level-according-new-polling/ ]