N※N

France criticised for ''inadequate'' probe into death of British wine boss

France Faces Sharp Criticism Over Flawed Investigation into Adama Traoré's Death

In a scathing rebuke that has reignited debates on police accountability and systemic racism in France, human rights organizations and legal experts have lambasted the French authorities for what they describe as an "inadequate" and "deeply flawed" probe into the 2016 death of Adama Traoré, a young Black man who died in police custody. The criticism, detailed in a recent report by Amnesty International and echoed by Traoré's family and supporters, highlights a pattern of investigative shortcomings that have left key questions unanswered and justice seemingly out of reach for the bereaved family. This case, which has become a symbol of alleged police brutality and racial injustice in France, continues to draw parallels to global movements like Black Lives Matter, underscoring the challenges faced by minority communities in seeking redress.

Adama Traoré, a 24-year-old resident of Beaumont-sur-Oise, a suburb north of Paris, died on July 19, 2016, shortly after being arrested by gendarmes during a routine identity check that escalated into a physical confrontation. According to initial reports, Traoré was pursued on foot after fleeing from officers who were attempting to detain his brother for questioning in an unrelated matter. Witnesses described a chaotic scene where Traoré was subdued using a controversial restraint technique, often referred to as "ventral decubitus" or prone restraint, which involves pinning a suspect face-down. He was then transported to a nearby gendarmerie station, where he was pronounced dead. The official cause of death was initially attributed to asphyxiation due to a pre-existing heart condition exacerbated by the chase and heat, but subsequent independent autopsies commissioned by the family have painted a starkly different picture, pointing to asphyxiation caused by the officers' actions.

The investigation into Traoré's death has been marred by allegations of bias, procedural errors, and a lack of transparency from the outset. Critics argue that the probe, overseen by the French judicial system, failed to adequately examine the role of the three gendarmes involved in the arrest. For instance, the officers were not immediately separated and questioned as per standard protocol to prevent collusion, allowing them to coordinate their statements. Moreover, key evidence, such as video footage from body cameras or surveillance systems, was either not collected promptly or deemed inconclusive. Amnesty International's report, released earlier this week, accuses the authorities of "systematic failures" that have "obstructed the truth" and denied the family a fair process. "The investigation has been riddled with inconsistencies, from conflicting medical reports to the dismissal of eyewitness testimonies that contradict the official narrative," the report states.

Traoré's sister, Assa Traoré, who has emerged as a prominent activist leading the "Justice for Adama" campaign, has been vocal in her condemnation of the handling of the case. In interviews and public statements, she has accused the French state of protecting its law enforcement officers at the expense of victims from marginalized communities. "This is not just about my brother; it's about a system that values some lives over others," Assa Traoré told reporters during a recent press conference in Paris. The family's legal team has filed multiple appeals, challenging the closure of the investigation in 2020, when a judge ruled that there was insufficient evidence to charge the officers with manslaughter or negligence. However, in a partial victory for the family, France's highest court, the Court of Cassation, ordered a reopening of the probe in 2022, citing procedural irregularities. Despite this, progress has been slow, with experts warning that the case could drag on for years without meaningful reforms.

The broader context of police violence in France adds layers to the criticism. Traoré's death occurred amid a wave of similar incidents involving ethnic minorities, reminiscent of the 2005 riots in Parisian suburbs sparked by the deaths of two teenagers fleeing police. More recently, the 2023 killing of Nahel Merzouk, a 17-year-old of Algerian descent shot by police during a traffic stop, sparked nationwide protests and drew international condemnation. Human rights groups like Human Rights Watch have linked these cases to entrenched issues within the French police force, including racial profiling, excessive use of force, and a culture of impunity. A 2021 study by the French Defender of Rights found that young men of Arab or Black descent are 20 times more likely to be subjected to identity checks than their white counterparts, fueling accusations of institutional racism.

Legal experts have pointed out specific inadequacies in the Traoré investigation that exemplify these systemic problems. For one, the initial autopsy, conducted by state-appointed pathologists, concluded that Traoré suffered from sickle cell disease and that his death was due to cardiogenic pulmonary edema triggered by stress and physical exertion. However, two independent medical examinations, including one by a Belgian expert, contradicted this, asserting that the prone restraint applied by the officers—pressing down on his back with their combined weight—led to positional asphyxia. These discrepancies have not been fully reconciled in court, with prosecutors often favoring the official reports. Furthermore, the investigation overlooked potential conflicts of interest: one of the pathologists involved had previously worked on cases defending police actions, raising questions about impartiality.

Amnesty International's report goes further, recommending urgent reforms to France's investigative framework. It calls for the establishment of an independent body to handle probes into police-related deaths, similar to models in the United Kingdom or Canada, where civilian oversight ensures transparency. "France's current system, where police investigate police, is inherently flawed and erodes public trust," said Marco Perolini, a researcher at Amnesty. The organization also urges the adoption of stricter guidelines on restraint techniques, banning methods like prone positioning that have been linked to fatalities worldwide. In response, French Interior Minister Gérald Darmanin has defended the gendarmerie's actions, stating that officers acted within the law and that the investigation has been thorough. However, he acknowledged the need for better training on de-escalation and cultural sensitivity, announcing in 2023 a series of workshops aimed at addressing racial bias in policing.

The Traoré case has not only galvanized domestic activism but has also attracted international scrutiny. The United Nations Human Rights Committee has expressed concerns over France's handling of police violence complaints, urging the government to comply with international standards under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. In the European context, the European Court of Human Rights has previously ruled against France in similar cases, such as the 2018 judgment on the death of Ali Ziri, an Algerian man who died in custody, criticizing inadequate investigations. Advocates hope that mounting pressure will lead to a precedent-setting outcome in the Traoré case, potentially forcing systemic changes.

For the Traoré family, the fight continues amid personal grief and public exhaustion. Assa Traoré has transformed her brother's death into a movement, organizing annual marches and publishing a book detailing their struggle. "We will not stop until the truth is acknowledged and those responsible are held accountable," she declared. Supporters, including celebrities like actor Omar Sy and musicians from the French hip-hop scene, have amplified the cause, drawing thousands to protests. Yet, the slow pace of justice has led to frustration, with some activists warning of escalating tensions if reforms are not implemented.

As France grapples with its identity as a republic founded on liberty, equality, and fraternity, the Adama Traoré case serves as a litmus test for its commitment to these ideals. Critics argue that without addressing the investigative failures exposed here, the cycle of distrust between law enforcement and minority communities will persist, potentially leading to more unrest. The government's response in the coming months—whether through legislative changes or a renewed push for accountability—will be closely watched, not just in France but around the world, as a measure of progress in the ongoing battle against police impunity and racial injustice.

This ongoing saga underscores a fundamental question: Can France's judicial system deliver impartial justice in cases involving its own institutions? For now, the criticism of the inadequate probe into Adama Traoré's death stands as a stark reminder of the work still needed to bridge the gap between rhetoric and reality in the pursuit of equality. (Word count: 1,248)

Read the Full The Telegraph Article at:
[ https://www.yahoo.com/news/france-criticised-inadequate-probe-death-172404767.html ]